Interview

Saving Nemo, History Edition

An interview with Kyle Harper, environmental historian and Christian
By Nadya Williams

In the introduction to his new book, The Last Animal (Princeton University Press, 2026), historian and classicist Kyle Harper describes wistfully looking at the landscape of his native Oklahoma and thinking about the fireflies he remembers seeing everywhere as a child—fireflies that are no longer around for his own children to observe in their backyard. Harper is a classicist and the former provost of the University of Oklahoma. He is the author of five books, and in the last three of these, he has been looking at different aspects of the history of human interactions with the natural world. How does living on the same planet as fireflies affect both us and the fireflies? And why is this a question of relevance for historians, rather than environmental scientists or biologists alone? 

As someone who has read all five of his books, I enjoyed the opportunity to interview Harper earlier this fall. I asked him questions about the larger story arc of his recent books, about his vision for writing history, and about the ways his faith informs his academic research.


Nadya Williams: In your book Plagues Upon the Earth: Disease and the Course of Human History, you made a very memorable statement: “It’s a microbe’s world. We’re just living in it.” Really, I got the impression from reading your last three books (The Fate of Rome, Plagues Upon the Earth, and now The Last Animal), that you have been telling pieces of a related bigger story: that human beings are obviously important, but we’re not the only ones who call this planet our home, and we’re not the only agents of historical change. 

Is it accurate to see these three books as a trilogy? What is the overall story that you are telling over the course of these three books, and how does The Last Animal complete this tale? Or might there be another book in the sequence?

Kyle Harper: Thank you for seeing the connection! You are on the right track. The Fate of Rome was my effort to understand how environmental factors like climate change and pandemic disease fit into the human story of how everyone’s favorite ancient empire fell. The Romans experienced three really consequential pandemic disease outbreaks (the Antonine Plague in the second century, the Cyprian Plague in the third, and the biggest of them all, the Justinianic Plague, in the sixth). In trying to write about these events, it piqued my interest in the bigger picture—why do we experience pandemics at all? Did all historical societies suffer similar episodes of infectious disease mortality? 

That was the motivation behind Plagues Upon the Earth, which is an effort to trace the deeper relationship between human history and infectious microbes. It is “big” or “deep” history, which to me means not only big in scale, but also entails an effort to see humans as part of the story of life, the story of the Earth, the story of the environment, and so on.

My new book, The Last Animal, is a follow-up to Plagues Upon the Earth. I wrote about microbes, and I wanted to understand how animals fit into the human story. I said in Plagues Upon the Earth that it was a kind of update to William McNeill’s Plagues and Peoples. I say in The Last Animal that he never wrote a similar book on animals, but if he had, it would be Animals and People, and my book is, in a way, an update to a book he didn’t write! 

NW: Central to your argument in The Last Animal is the concept of the “Sixth Extinction.” Could you please briefly explain what this is, for those who might not be familiar with the concept? 

KH: I’ll start with where the term and the idea come from, because it’s strange and revealing. The Sixth Extinction is an unusual combination of paleontology and conservation biology. It starts with the study of fossils. From the 1950s, people like the geologist (or paleobiologist) Norman Newell started to insist that the fossil record reveals the occurrence of true “mass extinctions.” This idea was pretty marginal for decades. It grated against the orthodox evolutionary view of gradualism. But eventually the data won out. And in the early 1980s, two paleobiologists published a landmark analysis of mass extinctions in the last 541 million years of life. It’s a bit tricky how you count a mass extinction (usually 75 percent of species disappear in a short time interval), and the idea became established that there had been five great extinction events.

That’s the paleontology side. Within a few years, by the early 1990s, scientists interested in the biodiversity crisis (like the legendary E.O. Wilson) started to compare the present loss of species to the past, to warn of a sixth mass extinction that we are causing. From the beginning it was rhetorical and polemical, and yet it also spawned a huge amount of good science, trying to measure extinction rates past and present.

Let me just say here that I think the Sixth Extinction is good to think with. My book is a kind of extended conversation about the merits and the limits of the idea. I do think what humans are doing will be dramatic and permanently etched in the fossil record. But read the book to see the whole argument! 

NW: How have you gotten interested in the history of climate and the environment, to begin with?  

KH: As usual with these things, from a combination of factors. Part of it is personal values and interests. I’m an outdoor guy. I love nature. I’d rather see our species not ruin it. Climate and biodiversity are great challenges of our times, and as a historian, I want to write history that is both true to the past and speaks to the present. 

Part of it is intellectual interests. I’ve always loved both the sciences and the humanities. You have to choose when you go to graduate school, but I have been lucky. I have been able to combine my interests. I benefited from mentors who encouraged working with people in other fields, like genetics. When I was a Ph.D. student, I was in the Harvard Med School labs, trying to scrape plague bacterium from the dental pulp of skeletons recovered in mass graves. It made an impression. 

I also think that some of the most interesting new things we are learning about the human past are coming out of partnership with people in natural scientific fields—from paleoclimatologists to archaogeneticists. So, part of my motivation is simply to be active along the frontiers where we are learning the most. The sequencing of the DNA of the plague (several years after we tried and failed, let it be noted!) is revolutionizing what we know of the great pandemics of the past. There is a thrill in these discoveries, and also a kind of deep satisfaction in “consilience,” seeing how knowledge from a variety of fields fits together. 

NW: Ancient historians (and, really, all historians) generally do not get much scientific training, but over the course of your last three books, you have been going deep into increasingly more scientific evidence alongside doing serious traditional historical research. And these books show the benefit of greater scientific understanding for historians! How have you acquired the research tools necessary for these projects? What would you tell other historians with related interests—what kinds of skills should they acquire to be able to write better histories of science and the environment? 

KH: It’s a challenge—for me, for everybody. It requires collaboration. There are nuances of biochemistry (among many other things) that I will never understand. There are nuances of how a sixth-century text works that friends in other fields will never really master. A lot of the best work is team research. But I do think it helps to be “literate” in other fields, understanding the language, methods, models, questions, and so on. Having tools for quantitative analysis is important, since math is the language of science. In my unpopular opinion, statistics courses should be required for doctoral work in history. I think it is self-limiting for the historical profession to ignore math. 

NW: On a related note, in your introduction, you write: “The goal of history—even scientific history—is ultimately humanistic: to help us know ourselves.” Can you explain this aim further? How does this philosophy affect the way you write history?

KH: In the humanities, we are interested in knowledge for its own sake. We are interested in questions of value and not only of fact. We are interested in the particular. The natural sciences differ in many ways. They are interested in the general, in the pattern, in cause and effect. But there are obvious areas of overlap. To understand how we fit into the story of biodiversity, we need the natural sciences. And yet, our goals might be more unabashedly about understanding ourselves and probing our values. So, I try to write a kind of history that self-consciously blends humanistic and scientific approaches. 

NW: One of the major themes to which you keep coming back in this book, based on the stories of different animals and regions, is that biodiversity is much more complicated than what most of us think—and also, biodiversity today is under much greater threat than most of us think. Can you explain? 

KH: Both of those seem true and important to me, from my reading of history.

Biodiversity is extremely complicated, but for reasons that are overdetermined, we often simplify it. For instance, we focus on species conservation. Preventing extinction is an unambiguously good thing. But it also leaves out other hierarchical levels of biological diversity, including higher ones (we might care about ecosystem diversity) or lower ones (we might care about subspecies diversity, like the various kinds of wolf all belonging to the same species that have been driven to extinction). 

It is also the case that the damage to biodiversity is already extensive. In the 1990s, fisheries ecologists started using the term “shifting baseline syndrome.” We have to start measuring somewhere, but very often, we start after change is already well underway. There is a longstanding tendency to count extinctions since 1500, for instance. But human alteration of the biosphere was already vast by 1500. I don’t emphasize this to be a pessimist. We need to be honest and realistic. A lot of this won’t be undone. But by taking stock of it, we can more honestly measure what remains (which is quite a lot!).  

NW: I assume that you went into this book project with some cautious assumptions—and lo, they proved to be true. Can you tell us about a couple of those? 

KH: I started the book with the hunch that it would be interesting to think of humanity’s ascent as a multi-species partnership, principally with our domesticated animals. That is a major theme of the story, and I hope I have sufficiently captured how amazing and strange our alliance with a handful of other animals is. I also wanted to think through how evolution threads through our history—our entire history. We tend to think of the domestication of animals as something that happened, past tense. But it is a story that has continued over thousands of years, right through the present. The evolutionary history of cattle, pigs, and chickens alone in the last 250 years or so is simply astonishing to me, and something that is underrated. I assumed that story would be interesting, and it certainly is to me. 

NW: On the flip side, writing a book project like this one also means encountering some surprises as well. Can you tell about a couple of such surprises—whether assumptions that were proven false, or something surprising that emerged from your research and that you were not expecting at all?

KH: To return to the earlier question, when I started the project, I was far more certain that we are causing a sixth mass extinction than I am at the end! And yet, things are also worse than I thought, too. 

I was continually surprised at the importance of unintended consequences. So much of the familiar natural world around us is the result of unintended consequences. The abundance of animals like coyotes and skunks, for instance. We have wiped out all the big predators, and so medium-sized predators fill in the gap.  

NW: Is there an inevitable trade-off between the growth of human civilization and the environment? If so, how can we manage this trade-off?

KH: Of course there are tradeoffs, but it’s not simple, it’s not either/or. If we think of the world as something to be stewarded and cared for, rather than a resource for our consumption, we will manage those tradeoffs very differently. Take an example that comes up throughout the book: the persecution of predators like wolves. Realistically, we cannot have wolves everywhere in our midst. The tension is real! But if we understand and respect wolves, rather than view them as entirely disposable, we can approach the question of how to ensure the planet leaves a place for them too. 

NW: You are an academic historian, and you are also a Christian. In what ways (if any) do you find these two identities contributing to each other? 

KH: I suspect, and hope, that deep down we all do scholarship that matters to us, that flows out of our commitments to the world and our desire to understand those commitments. Christianity can foster very different attitudes to the natural world—there are huge differences between imagining human dominion over nature and human stewardship of nature. You won’t be surprised which I find more correct and more inspiring. I think understanding how precious, unique, and fragile the living world is supports an ethic of loving and stewarding that world.

Nadya Williams is senior fellow at the Ashbrook Center at Ashland University. She serves as managing editor of Mere Orthodoxy, for which she also hosts the Christians Reading Classics podcast.

ARC welcomes letters to the editor

Write to Us