Essay

Kid Fears

My evangelical upbringing made me unwilling to have children. But I can’t go no-contact with Christianity.
By Carlene Bauer

In the summer of 2015, I stood in a bathroom brushing my teeth while listening to NPR tell me that Trump had declared his run for the presidency. As I brushed and listened, something I cannot bear to call intuition made me wonder—

What if this guy ends up being the antichrist? 

I had been raised evangelical in the eighties, in the final years of the Cold War, and had been subjected to more end-times fever-dreaming than was psychically helpful for a child whose tiny mind had been, it turns out, genetically programmed to go up in anxious, mile-high flames. And I’d grown up in churches and Christian schools that subscribed, either overtly or tacitly, to the belief that Jesus might indeed return in our lifetimes, and that headlines, specifically those involving the Soviet Union and Israel, could be harbingers of the terrible time that would precede the Second Coming. 

One of my most formative memories was of a film, shown in churches as something of an altar call, in which a young woman hears on the radio one hazy 1970s summer morning that people have disappeared en masse from an amusement park. We the viewers are given to understand what the young woman does not: that the rapture is underway and shit is about to hit the fan. The moment in which the radio issues forth this news and ushers in a new unsettling reality has stayed with me all my life. Mostly, I can say now, because it’s actually pretty great filmmaking, in that the absolute stillness of this scene creates a powerful sense of dread. But it also instilled in me this fear: that we would learn about the beginning of the end from such an ordinary-seeming news break. 

Depending on where we were in what we now call a news cycle, I would avoid being anywhere near a newscast or newspaper or a Time magazine, and the panic was such that no adult could relieve me of it. Well, no—that’s not quite right. One adult did, eventually: Gorbachev. And then the Berlin Wall fell, and history “ended,” and I went off to college and then New York City, determined to prove to myself that all the anxiety exhibited by the adults in charge around what to read, listen to, watch, say, or befriend had sprung out of the perennial human inability to tell (to borrow some words from the Nicene Creed) Light from Light and true God from true God. For many years, I was able to almost completely forget that I had been such a frightened little kid. 

As an adult, I absolutely refused to succumb to these fears, which I wanted to call irrational. That was the dark; here all around me in the city was light—people, art, the more or less peaceful coexistence of multitudes. I finished brushing my teeth, put on some lipstick, and left the apartment to meet a friend for drinks in the city. New York: if you lived here long enough, you could pretend you’d thrown off every last piece of nonsense that had either clipped your wings or distorted your thoughts as a child. Back when you were too young to know how to question the adults telling you these stories and too young to trust in your own sense of what God really wanted from those who cried out to him. 

Some days I can say that I delivered myself from Christianity’s worst parts. Some days I cannot. 

Ten years later: everything that comes out of Trump’s mouth is an apocalypse. As is every breaking news alert crashing into my inbox. Out of the radio flies shrapnel, every hour on the hour, and whenever it does, I recall the warning Jesus gave to the disciples when they pressed him for signs of the end: Wars and rumors of wars. But I need to believe that life is still worth living, even as my country turns itself into the Germany we once rescued the world from, so I turn the radio off and delete those emails without reading them. 

Whenever I reach out my hand to silence the radio, which I find I am still doing even after the seeming reprieve of the midterms, I think about how so many of us are rationing the amount of news we consume and wonder if we’re all the eight-year-old I used to be—terrorized as we are by others’ longings for final violent correctives. To be clear, the eschatological narratives I encountered were nowhere near as flagrant in their debasement of the gospel as the so-called Christianity that views Trump’s sins as the price to pay for ushering in a government that reflects their punitive worldview. The longing for apocalypse I encountered was not a desire for retribution, I want to say, as much as it was an expression of a wish to be delivered from a place that was not home.

I take a little bit of comfort in remembering that Dorothy Day and Thomas Merton advised us to keep our distance from the radio—they knew that the media’s amplification of human-derived chaos had the ability to occlude the presence or possibility of the divine. But still. I’ve spent most of my life as an avid, assiduous consumer of news, and I resent being sent back to this place, and resent being put there in part by people who call themselves Christian. I am enraged by the fact that the person we used to call a secretary of defense is apparently fueled by a lust for Armageddon and understands our illegal war with Iran as a holy war. Two days after the midterm elections, which can be rightly read as a rebuke of the war he won’t give up on, he announced that he had no intention of resigning. 

It’s a struggle to force myself to read more than headlines for articles about this and other manifestations of unconscionable, unbelievable Christian extremism. It is too painful and frightening to contemplate the fact that the delusions that traumatized me as a child might, whether through one Pete or another,  one day be responsible for annihilating all we hold dear. 

In going back to the Bible to confirm that Wars and rumors of wars was indeed what Jesus had said to the disciples, I see he also told them this: 

And woe unto them that are with child, and to them that give suck in those days!

I had completely forgotten about this verse, but it had haunted me as a child. The girl I was did not want to contemplate such an inhospitable world or the distress of the mothers and babies who would have to suffer it, even though she could already feel a definite disinterest in becoming a mother gathering within her. That girl loved the world—its oceans and books, its people and music—and could already sense that she did not need to have children to amplify her enjoyment of it. She hated to think that one day she and everyone in it would be stopped in the middle of a day and swept off the face of it by the rapture, or the nuclear war that would precede the rapture. The way all the Pompeiians had been murdered in broad daylight by the omnivorous rivers of lava tumbling ceaselessly from the mouth of Vesuvius. One way the girl loved the world was through her fascination with all the people who had lived and died before her. 


That girl is partly why I do not have children of my own. She is my only daughter. 

I chose not to mother because there were other things I thought I wanted to do with my time, but it is also true that remembering just how anxious I’d been as a child made me unwilling to have children of my own. 

I could think of nothing worse than bringing a child into this world only for her to see she had a mind that could not be soothed by the adults around her. If she loved me but I could not take away her pain, what would be the point of me? Of us? Of life? I could not bear watching a child suffer like that. And she surely would be a frightened child, for anxiety and depression, I saw the older I got, ran in my family like blue eyes, alcoholism, and heart disease. Even if I made sure not to raise her with any religion, or harmful religion, life would surely give her mind some reason to become inflamed, and there the two of us would be, helpless and in pain. In some purgatorial Egypt like Mary and the infant Jesus, perpetually in flight and never at rest. 

There was a moment, not too long ago, where I started to wonder whether this decision—whether my entire life!—had been too informed by this and other fears. But the constant chaos of the last six years has made me relieved—relieved in a way I never have been—to have never had children. I’m relieved that my fears are the only ones I need to assuage as I watch stupidity and hatred eat my country alive. Relieved that I do not have to figure out how to quell a child’s anxiety over the hate running through the world and do not have to have my heart broken by their pain when they cannot make sense of it. Relieved that I will not have to lie or otherwise fail them in whatever attempt I make to save them from the sleepless nights that will result from the prospect of catastrophe.

You would think this personal history would make me sympathetic to generations younger than mine who fear the apocalypse that will be induced by climate change and have decided not to have children because of it. It does not. Of course some of this might come from being a Gen Xer who possesses a reflexive distrust of most Millennial objections and the butthurtedness with which they love to make these objections known. 

But it’s more than that. In this recusal I sense a rejection of the world as it is—an inability to accept its failure to keep us safe—that too closely resembles that of the world-hatred preached to me growing up. I want to say also that this rejection of risk differs from mine in that it wasn’t the world and its evils that gave me pause as much as it was my own ability to help whatever child I might have feel safe. And children should feel safe. 

The constant chaos of the last six years has made me relieved—relieved in a way I never have been—to have never had children.

This progressive pessimism and others like it—such as the ones motivating left-wing preppers and those who decenter romance—understand the world as fallen and therefore a scandal. I know these pessimists see these recusals as protests against extractive, capitalist, and patriarchal systems, but they read to me as carrying just as much world-suspicion as the evangelicalism I was raised with. This is an apocalypse more troubling to me than the one we’ll suffer due to climate collapse: watching those who take pride in not letting themselves be oppressed by religion consent to oppress themselves with versions of the paranoia and puritanism I spent my life running away from. Evangelical Christianity insisted that I be suspicious of all those willing to gamble on thriving outside its narrow confines, and so whenever the unchurched willingly and self-righteously build themselves bunkers to get away from systems or people or bodies of thought—whether literally or figuratively, whether left or the right, and especially the left—I need to get myself far away from those scenes. 

But there’s an apocalypse even more troubling to me than the ones described above. When I look around on the subway, all I see are people hunched over their phones in a way that makes me think of fetuses floating without agency or aim in darkness, curled up in on themselves to get as close as possible to their source of life. Or what I’m seeing is a forest full of stumps—full of trees burnt down to half their former size by a wildfire no one thinks it necessary to contain. A forest felled. 

Watching humans consent to stop being fully human on a daily basis frightens me more than the fact that human-caused natural disasters are what makes the world beautiful and livable. When I look around me on the subway and on the street I think: it’s already gone. Technology is leaching the world of all animating spirit the way global warming has leached all the pink from the coral that makes up the Great Barrier Reef. 

I realize I am supposed to pause here and say something about how fucked up Christianity is and how fucked up it is that adults expose children to its more violent aspects before they’re equipped to distinguish fantasy from reality. It’s been suggested to me by therapists and others that I could call what I experienced religious trauma. I do mostly believe what happened was that—or, you know, probably was that. But the diagnosis doesn’t take away the pain of knowing that this upbringing might have made my heart unavailable for more than just parenting. I resist shrinking my experience down into something that could be so easily labeled, and would love to think this resistance could be interpreted as more than just a boundless capacity for living in denial.

Even though I absolutely do think it is fucked up whenever adults find it necessary to immiserate children—or their fellow citizens—through religion, I find I cannot be as angry at religion as my times have long required me to be. Anger at religion can sound just as obsessive, small-minded, and morally superior to me as the stuff that comes out of the mouths of the aggressively churched. It’s as boring to me as anger at men. Anger only wants to tell one story. And for whatever reason—whether it’s in reaction to the evangelical Christianity I was raised with, or temperament, or both—I break out in hives whenever anyone insists that there’s only one story—that there’s only one way to read a book, or to live, or to think, or to paint, or to have sex. 

Christianity gave me and goes on giving me much more than waking nightmares. I know the Nicene Creed by heart but do not believe in every word of it. And yet I find myself reaching for the words and images of Christianity whenever I need consolation or anchoring or to be reminded of how and why to love. There are so many other words and images to reach for—and yes, it does seem especially necessary to choose them now, when Christianity is being used, once again, as a cover for fascism and white supremacy. But Christianity lives inside me like a first language. Lines from scripture and hymns come to me unbidden, and constantly. I can’t be free of them—I learned them too young and heard them too often—and don’t know that I want to be free of them. They taught me forgiveness and keep me aspiring to forgiveness. They’re one of the main reasons why I can never turn right. 

This is what love is, I sometimes think: knowing that a person is flawed and disappointing and enraging and yet insisting on seeing the good in them. This is what happened when Dorothy Day encountered the Catholic Church. She took a look at it and thought: I can do something with this hypocritical, chronically unjust old thing. Simone Weil, too. So perhaps love requires imagination, which I would love to say is different from blindness, ignorance, and innocence. I don’t need to believe that love will conquer all, but I need to believe that its light is as palpable and real as darkness. As tenacious as evil—and as strong, as it says in the Song of Songs, as death.

Carlene Bauer is a writer living in Brooklyn. Her most recent book is the novel Girls They Write Songs About.

ARC welcomes letters to the editor

Write to Us