Essay

Taxonomy of Hate

After World War II, a Jewish nonprofit hired world-famous scholars to study antisemitism. Their conclusions are useful today.
By Amy Sohn
“The Philosopher,” a portrait of Norbert Guterman, by Betty Hubbard

The first chapter of the 1949 book Prophets of Deceit opens like this: “When will the plain, ordinary, sincere, sheeplike people of America awaken to the fact that their common affairs are being arranged and run for them by aliens, Communists, crackpots, refugees, renegades, Socialists, termites, and traitors?… Oh, this is a clever scheme and if the American people don’t get busy and fight it the whole vicious thing will be slipped over on you without your knowing what hit you.” The fictional speech, “The Agitator Speaks,” is a pastiche comprising the words of actual American antisemites of the time, including Catholic priest and radio star Charles Coughlin, Christian Mobilizer founder Joseph E. McWilliams, and populist clergyman Gerald L.K. Smith.

Prophets of Deceit was the first volume in Studies in Prejudice, a remarkable series of books published between November 1949 and March 1950. The five volumes used analysis and sociology to unpack the manipulations of World War II–era American agitators. The hope was that by explaining how the rhetoric deployed by these agitators worked, they could be defanged—made less dangerous. While published by Harper & Brothers, the series was funded by the American Jewish Committee, which spent $175,000 ($2.5 million in today’s dollars) to bring the series into print. It was surely one of the largest private expenditures ever to support social science research. 

The speeches and writings of the agitators are especially resonant in a time of rising antisemitism. I first read Prophets of Deceit last year, but reread it during a midterm campaign season featuring caricatures of Israel and AIPAC by Democrats and Republicans alike, which hearkened back to tropes of power-hungry and dangerous international financiers.

The mastermind of Studies in Prejudice was John Slawson, who had become the executive vice president of the American Jewish Committee (AJC) in 1943. Under his leadership, the AJC entered a golden era of social science research. By hiring European Marxists who were suddenly without classrooms, and charging them with the task of explaining the authoritarian mind, the AJC instantly became nearly as important to social science research as Harvard or the University of Chicago. It was a brief, shining moment when Jewish thriving was equated with supporting rigorous scholarship. And in our own moment, when the U.S. president has argued that antisemitism is best combatted by threatening cuts to academic research, it is worth looking back at this lost golden era.

The AJC was not a natural home for social science research. Formed in 1906 by wealthy German Jewish philanthropists including Jacob Schiff (who had made his money in railroads), Oscar Straus (department stores), and Cyrus Sulzberger (imports), it was more of a monied clique than a think tank. As historian and author of the 1997 book Jews Against Prejudice: American Jews and the Fight for Civil Liberties Stuart Svonkin recounts, Schiff, Straus, and Sulzberger were “American equivalents of the court Jews, or shtadlan, the traditional intermediary between the Jewish community and civil society in preemancipation Europe.” In a 1981 oral history interview, Slawson explained that, despite its founding in 1906, the AJC “didn’t have a strong group approach to the problems in Europe that began in the beginning of the century.”

Slawson had a new vision for how these wealthy Jews could help their people. Born in Ukraine in 1896, Slawson fled pogroms with his family at age seven. After halting his education to work, he finished high school and then studied at Valparaiso University in Indiana and at the University of Kansas before completing college and a doctorate—in psychology, in 1927—at Columbia. After holding several positions at Jewish charities, he joined the AJC. 

As Slawson watched the rise of the Nazi Party in Germany, he became convinced that prejudice was a “disease of the personality.” The antisemite, “more so than others, was a person that would be described as authoritarian, meaning … things had to be his way and he had very little relationships with outside people.” If people could understand antisemitism as a “mental health problem,” Slawson said, it could help “make it unfashionable.” Slawson wanted to use his academic training to solve the global problems of antisemitism and prejudice. The question was who would help him.

Fascism supplied the answer. After Hitler’s rise to power, Jewish members of the Frankfurt-based Institute for Social Research (ISR) had fled Germany, many landing at Columbia. They had for some time been studying the causes and development of National Socialism; the mentality of the German worker; and fascist tendencies in Europe. The general conclusions of the Frankfurt School, as their movement, synthesizing Marxism, sociology, and psychoanalytic theory, was called, held that authoritarianism was the result of capitalism and its effects, not merely the psychologies of individuals. 

In 1941, the ISR, now based in New York, drafted a research project for studying modern antisemitism, and it got an AJC grant to develop the project; in the spring of 1944, the ISR scholars presented 1,200 pages to the AJC. Then, in May 1944, Slawson invited a group of about 25 social scientists, including Max Horkheimer, the leader of the ISR, and other ISR members to a New York City convening to “correlate the findings of the Institute of Social Research with the knowledge and experience of American social scientists who are recognized authorities in the field of minority group problems, or Jewish group relations, or in allied fields.” 

The group included academics in sociology, psychology, psychiatry, economics, and political science, from Yale, Harvard, and the New York School for Social Research. Half were Jewish. They discussed the causes of prejudice against religious, racial, and ethnic groups. The gathering birthed the AJC’s Department of Scientific Research, whose primary accomplishment during its approximately two-decade tenure would be Studies in Prejudice.

The remit of Studies, as the AJC Reporter announced, was to research areas “in which the unit of study is the group, the institution and the community, rather than the individual.” The AJC wanted to “constitute a reservoir of new knowledge, yielding better methods for the protection of democracy against the inroads of bigotry and the onslaughts of totalitarianisms.” Commentary would call Studies “the largest research project ever undertaken into the nature of anti-Semitism.” 

Slawson selected Horkheimer to direct the new department and edit Studies (an American, Samuel Flowerman, succeeded him as director and was coeditor of the series). To author the books, Horkheimer selected European and American intellectuals and academics. Rehearsal for Destruction: A Study of Political Anti-Semitism in Imperial Germany (1949) was by German sociologist Paul W. Massing; Dynamics of Prejudice: A Psychological and Sociological Study of Veterans (1950) was by Bruno Bettelheim and sociologist Morris Janowitz; Anti-Semitism and Emotional Disorder: A Psychoanalytic Interpretation (1950) was by psychoanalyst Nathan Ackerman and social psychologist Marie Jahoda; and the most famous of all of them, The Authoritarian Personality (1950), the final, 1,000-page volume, was by German theorist Theodor Adorno, Austrian psychologist Else Frenkel-Brunswik, and Berkeley psychologists Daniel Levinson and Nevitt Sanford.

Horkheimer’s original vision, never realized, was that each book be a small booklet, to be given out during outbreaks of antisemitism to teachers, students, and politicians—those he considered “multiplicators,” the twentieth-century term for influencers. He saw it as a political-educational mass inoculation program.

In our own moment, when the U.S. president has argued that antisemitism is best combatted by threatening cuts to academic research, it is worth looking back at this lost golden era.

To write Prophets of Deceit, Horkheimer selected German Jew Leo Löwenthal and Polish Jew Norbert Guterman, both born in 1900. Löwenthal, a Marxist literary scholar, had joined the ISR in 1926. He contributed articles on literature and plays to the ISR’s journal, Zeitschrift für Sozialforschung, and became its managing editor. After the ISR was forced to leave Germany, Löwenthal coordinated its New York and Los Angeles branches. He said he was paid $10,000 for Prophets of Deceit. Assuming Guterman was paid the same amount, their total advance would have equaled around $280,000 in today’s dollars.

Guterman had in 1921 emigrated from Poland to France, where he studied philosophy at the Sorbonne and, beginning in 1929, edited the journal Revue Marxiste, using a pseudonym. After a Communist newspaper published his real name, making him a target for expulsion, he emigrated to the U.S. In New York, he became a book reviewer and translator for The New Republic and The Partisan Review and an associate of the ISR.

As the cultural critic Alberto Toscano points out in his introduction to a 2021 reissue of Prophets of Deceit, the book’s roots can be found in a 1944-1945 ISR study on “Anti-Semitism Among American Labor,” funded by the Jewish Labor Committee but never published. In it, Löwenthal argued that wartime American workers’ stereotype of Jews as aggressive, superior, and clannish came from their perception that Jews had created “a sphere of independence in a world of interdependence, a sphere of autarchy in a world of mutual dependency, a sphere of license in a world of restrictions.” He would return to this theme in Prophets.


To write the book, Löwenthal and Guterman pored over pamphlets and speeches by “native fascists” from the early 1930s and the end of World War II. Then they sat around and talked. Guterman took notes on what Löwenthal said and typed them.

Löwenthal and Guterman wanted readers to view the contemporary American agitator not as a copy of a “foreign model” or “a crackpot whose appeals and goals derive neither from domestic conditions nor from native attitudes” but, instead, as its own beast. They studied the speeches and writings using a qualitative content analysis, which they referred to as a “psychological Morse code.” 

The American agitator, they argued, preyed on the subconscious. To understand how he did it and to resist him, Americans had to read his actual words. For the chapter “The Agitator Speaks,” Löwenthal and Guterman asked their friend Irving Howe, the famed literary critic, to compile a speech based on real materials. (In 1976, Howe would write a book that ended up on every Jewish grandparent’s bookshelf, World of Our Fathers, about the lost world of Eastern European Jewry.)

Psychoanalysis looms large over Prophets of Deceit. In its portrayal of the mind games of American antisemitic agitators like Coughlin and Smith, agitation is not only dangerous but unenlightened. Whereas psychoanalysis leads to curiosity and discovery, agitation reinforces “neurotic and even psychotic behavior culminating in perpetual dependency on a ‘leader.’” Unlike a (presumably benevolent) analyst, the agitator’s goal is to “conceal from his followers the very possibility of independent thinking and autonomous decision” that could allow him to understand the world rationally and choose to reject hatred.

One of the delights of the book is its taxonomy of hate. The authors enumerate the agitator’s antisemitic stereotypes in sections with titles like The Jew as Anti-Christ, Ferment, Clannishness, Cunning, Vindictiveness, and Mimicking, and remind us again and again of the tropes’ self-contradictory nature. The Jew should be kept away from the community, but he is seclusive. He is disloyal to the U.S., but that is to be expected: “No one should expect from an American Jew the same devotion to American traditions,” the authors quote the Defenders of the Christian Faith magazine, from 1939. The Jew is portrayed “both as weak and strong, victim of persecution and persecutor, endowed with unchangeable racial characteristics and irrepressible individualism.” In a way, he is enviable. Who wouldn’t want to be an irrepressible individual?


I grew up with many Jewish friends in a leafy part of Brooklyn, attended a Reform Jewish synagogue, and helped to lead my city-wide youth group. I had little exposure to antisemitism except in movies and plays. But I was obsessed with it anyway.

In eighth grade, for a social studies project, I chose to deconstruct Joseph Goebbels’s posters of Aryan youth and families, explaining the messages Goebbels was sending to Germans about physical strength, superiority, and family. In my senior year of high school, my Yiddish-speaking, secular grandmother took me to a lecture by Sander Gilman, who had just published The Jew’s Body. She bought me the book, which Gilman signed. Reading the book, I pored over 19th-century caricatures of Jews with their hands held down, palms to the body, fingers in gaudy rings, noses beaked, spectacles low on the nose. I could see with my own eyes how facts—Jews as jewelers and moneylenders—were distorted by antisemites to imagine a physical body that was ugly, old, and even homosexual.

In my senior year at Brown, I chose to write a thesis on antisemitism in Brown admissions. My other grandmother had attended Pembroke, Brown’s women’s college, during the 1920s, and told me there had been Jewish quotas, which I initially thought meant a Jewish minimum. For my thesis research, I read antisemitic Ivy League songs and college humor papers with caricatures of Jewish students. I read admission files filled with nasty stereotypes, and I read policy papers on how to limit the percentage of Jewish students. I even found antisemitic writing about my own grandmother, never seen by her, by a professor she considered a mentor.

None of this made me feel sick. It made me high. I was Columbo. I could not believe the material was unredacted or even hard to request. There is an elation in knowing what they think of you.

When I first read Prophets of Deceit, I felt something similar. It was the mix of text and metatext that grabbed me, the 1940s invective unpacked by two brainy, calm intellectuals named Leo and Norbert. Löwenthal and Guterman act as gentle, gallant decoders; privately they were surely mourning the murders of family and friends. 


As much as it diagnoses the agitator’s methods and manipulations, behind all this the book diagnoses what seems to be a societal problem. It argues that the individualism possessed by the Jews is seductive to the agitator’s followers because “individual happiness seems to become so exceptional that the presence of a group that seemingly continues to pursue it is felt as an affront and a menace.” The followers feel distrust, dependence, exclusion, anxiety, and disillusionment. Together, these feelings “form a fundamental condition of modern life: malaise.” 

Happiness “exceptional”? A national “malaise”? Wait—weren’t Americans in the postwar economic boom feeling pretty happy? Or are the authors only talking about certain Americans? 

The supposed malaise, they contend, stems from “the stresses imposed on the individual by the profound transformations taking place in our economic and social structure—the replacement of the class of small independent producers by gigantic industrial bureaucracies, the decay of the patriarchal family, the breakdown of primary personal ties between individuals in an increasingly mechanized world, the compartmentalization and atomization of group life, and the substitution of mass culture for traditional patterns.” 

What does all this sound like? Capitalism! 

But what is the solution, if what makes the agitator’s followers so ill is capitalism itself, that inescapable, hegemonic system? Instead of urging the reader toward communism (it was 1949 after all), Löwenthal and Guterman propose more scholarship: we must gain “diagnostic insight into the latest threat against democracy.” The book could “pave the way for an empirical exploration of the psychology of the agitator and for field work on his actual effects upon audiences.” Exposing the social and psychological content of agitation is the “prerequisite for its prophylaxis.” How scientific.

As Martin Jay, the foremost historian of the Frankfurt School, writes, whereas ISR’s early “image of mental health implied a left-wing negation of the status quo,” later “the ‘healthy liberal’ who advocated piecemeal reform became the model of sanity.” Elsewhere, Jay called the antisemite’s antagonist the “democratic personality” or “genuine liberal.”


It turns out that 1949 was a good time to be a liberal advocating piecemeal reform. Studies in Prejudice was successful, and not just among academics. The volume Prophets of Deceit was widely reviewed by scientific and general-interest publications. Lowenthal said the book “did have an influence, especially among students and instructors in the field of mass communications research.”

At a Spring 1950 party at Manhattan’s Lotus Club celebrating the release of the final volume, one hundred sociologists and psychologists, along with representatives of Fortune, Look, NBC, Seventeen, Newsweek, the Urban League, the National Negro Press Association, The New York Times, the New School, Harper & Brothers, and the ACLU, raised their glasses. Slawson said he hoped the “new insights afforded us by psychology, psychiatry and the other social sciences” would “help build a social climate unreceptive to racial and religious tensions between neighbor and neighbor.”

The AJC branched out from the Studies to develop anti-prejudice programs, lesson plans, and a mass media campaign to increase tolerance. It collaborated with the NAACP, the ACLU, and various Christian groups on what came to be called “intergroup relations,” and the focus on antisemitism expanded to encompass anti-black racism. A 1950 AJC study of school segregation by Kenneth Clark was cited in Brown v. Board of Education (1954). Yet the AJC’s Department of Scientific Research (later the Division of Scientific Research) appears to have been disbanded in the mid-1960s. 

The 1960s and the Vietnam War created a split between left-leaning Jewish Baby Boomers, who became less concerned with antisemitism and more concerned with racial equality and freedom of speech, and right-leaning Jewish Baby Boomers, concerned about the security of Israel and vigilant against antisemitism. To this first group, a book focused on antisemitism, so modern in 1949, would have felt backward in 1969. 


The final section of Prophets of Deceit is called “The Agitator Means.” Written by Irving Howe, it is a deconstruction of “The Agitator Speaks” that reveals the things the agitator is really telling you. “We will offer you scapegoats,” the imagined agitator says, “Jews, radicals, plutocrats, and other creatures conjured by our imagination.”

Whose imagination is doing the conjuring of Jews today? The right-wing agitator, to be sure: the well-scrubbed and smiling Tucker Carlson, the equally jolly Candace Owens, the smarmy Nick Fuentes. Wielding power in a different way are elected Democrats who refuse to condemn Hamas, or who campaign alongside those who call Jews “inbred” and compare them to Nazis, or who share Instagram posts alleging that the massacre of Jews at Bondi Beach in Australia was a false flag operation by “Zionists” (the new congressman Chris Rabb, from Philadelphia, blamed the post on a “former staffer,” which is hardly much better).

In this month’s midterm elections, Republicans were trounced by a mix of “revolutionaries” and “healthy liberals.” As many of these revolutionaries campaigned by vilifying the Israeli army, AIPAC, “real estate money,” and “corporate PACs”—characterizations grounded, as all stereotypes are, in true things—I thought repeatedly of Father Coughlin’s clannish, money-hungry Jews.

During the McCarthy Era, Leo Löwenthal was the research director for the federal government’s Voice of America, which became a target of McCarthy lawyers Roy Cohn and David Schine. Though Löwenthal was never called to testify before the House Un-American Activities Committee, an eventuality that he considered “unfortunate,” he was interviewed about his political beliefs by a State Department civil servant as part of a “security investigation.” The man said that in Prophets of Deceit, Löwenthal had only investigated the material of right-wing agitators. Löwenthal answered that the book was written on assignment from the AJC and the assignment was to write about antisemitic agitators. 

Decades later, Löwenthal told an interviewer, “The Communists might well be very wicked, but in the United States they aren’t antisemitic, at least not in terms of their ideology.” One can only wonder whether he would hold to that assertion if he were alive today.

 

Amy Sohn is the author of 12 books, including the award-winning The Man Who Hated Women and the novels Prospect Park West and Motherland. Her new work of narrative non-fiction, about Jewish men in the 1950s, will be out with Metropolitan Books in 2028.

ARC welcomes letters to the editor

Write to Us