Letters to the Editor

Liberal Catholicism

An exchange Between Jack Hanson and Paul Baumann
By Arc Magazine

On October 22, 2026, Arc published “The Limitations of Liberal Catholicism,” in which Paul Baumann criticized, among other writings, Jack Hanson’s “Radical Reformation,” from the August issue of Harper’s. We received this letter from Hanson:

With all due respect to Mr. Baumann, whose work I’ve long admired and whose liberal bona fides are, as he points out, almost beyond reproach, I found his objections to, or frustrations with, my Harper’s essay to be selective bordering on the tendentious, and informed more by his (understandable) annoyance with the essay’s subheading than with much of what I actually argued. At the risk of seeming defensive: tasked with explaining how, to much of the outside world, the Church’s reputation has undergone such a drastic transformation in the recent past, I offered a read on the last 150 years of political Catholicism, trying to show that yes, there is a long tradition of what I guess we have to call “progressivism” in Church doctrine, but also that its political history, including its apparent capitulations to fascist regimes in the twentieth century, has always been more complex than a purely secular account could explain. Perhaps I should have made more references to Eucharistic theology, or the centrality of Mary, or any of the other strangenesses that make Catholicism so challenging and so alluring—can I appeal to the agonies of the word count? In any case, far from trying to “lobotomize us away from a sense of sin,” I see my essay as part of an attempt to, among other things, dramatically expand how we have tended to think about sin in recent decades, beyond personal propriety and toward the foundations of our society, the sins we not only commit, but seem to depend upon committing, indeed can hardly recognize, let alone escape, whatever our political preferences. But, then, I’m not really a liberal.

Paul Baumann sent us this reply:

First, I’d like to thank Jack Hanson for his gracious rejoinder to my characterization of his article. I regret that he found my necessarily brief account of his piece tendentious. His essay was indeed a learned and sympathetic “read on the last 150 years of political Catholicism,” emphasizing the often neglected and misunderstood “progressive” nature of Church teaching. What I found perplexing was his suggestion that the teachings of Popes Francis and Leo XIV represent a dramatic break from their immediate predecessors and thereby a “renewal of the radical reforms” of Vatican II. How radical those reforms were is, as I’m sure Hanson knows, a subject of endless contention. In making that claim, however, Hanson never discusses exactly what those reforms were or how they specifically sanctioned his rightful concerns over political and economic justice. In fact, Hanson’s discussion of the Church’s progressive doctrines calls into question just how theologically radical Vatican II was, since the teachings he celebrates, as he notes in his letter, predate the 1962-65 council. Finally, like Hanson, I’m all in favor of expanding how we think about sin “beyond personal propriety and toward the foundations of our society,” but I suspect it is easier to do that if we firmly hold onto traditional notions of sin at the same time. In that spirit, I apologize and ask to be forgiven for being tendentious.  


ARC welcomes letters to the editor

Write to Us